School of Humanities and Social Sciences at North South University

School of Humanities and Social Sciences (SHSS) at North South University (NSU) organized a faculty seminar on February 5 to examine philosophical and ethical questions surrounding Anthropic’s artificial intelligence model, Claude.

School of Humanities and Social Sciences at North South University
School of Humanities and Social Sciences at North South University

Titled “A Philosophical Critique of Anthropic’s ‘Constitution’ for its AI Model ‘Claude,’” the seminar brought together faculty members, academics, researchers, and students for an in-depth discussion on artificial intelligence ethics, AI governance, and philosophy, according to a press release. The session was moderated by Md. Mehedi Hasan, senior lecturer in the Department of English and Modern Languages at NSU.

Keynote presentation was delivered by Prof. Dr. Norman Kenneth Swazo, director of the Office of Research and professor of philosophy in the Department of History and Philosophy at NSU. He critically examined Anthropic’s “constitutional AI” approach, which claims to guide Claude’s behavior through embedded ethical principles related to safety, privacy, and accuracy.

Prof. Swazo questioned whether constitution-based AI governance can meaningfully support claims of ethical reasoning, moral judgment, or consciousness, especially given artificial systems’ lack of lived experience and contextual understanding. He argued that while AI models like Claude can simulate complex human-like behavior, such simulation does not amount to genuine consciousness.

During the question-and-answer session, participants asked whether constitutionally guided AI systems could ever develop consciousness, given their reliance on pattern recognition rather than understanding. Prof. Swazo expressed skepticism, citing neuroscientist Anil Seth, who argues that “simulation is not instantiation.”

Further discussion focused on the limits of machine learning compared with human moral fallibility and whether society places excessive ethical responsibility on AI systems. Addressing concerns about accountability when individuals are influenced by AI-generated outputs, Prof. Swazo distinguished between AI-induced and AI-associated psychosis, suggesting such cases should be examined through psychopathology rather than attributing responsibility to AI systems. He emphasized that Claude operates within predefined ethical constraints and does not exercise moral autonomy.

Participants also raised questions about copyright, access to knowledge, and fairness, particularly whether AI systems trained on vast amounts of publicly available data could advantage students without access to academic resources. Prof. Swazo noted that Claude’s training includes millions of books and legally available materials, while acknowledging that Anthropic has settled lawsuits related to copyright violations, underscoring ongoing ethical tensions.

Another question addressed how the absence of consciousness in AI systems can be assessed. Prof. Swazo acknowledged the difficulty of proving a negative but argued that observable behavior demonstrates that AI “knowledge” lacks the depth and complexity of human cognition.

Following the lecture, Md. Rizwanul Islam, professor of law and dean of SHSS at NSU, highlighted that ethical frameworks embedded in AI systems may reflect cultural and ideological biases shaped by their socio-cultural origins. He stressed that the critical issue lies not only in AI design but also in how societies critically engage with and respond to emerging technologies.

Similar Posts